Advertisement
Advertisement


target="_blank" vs. target="_new"


Question

What's the difference between <a target="_new"> and <a target="_blank"> and which should I use if I just want to open a link in a new tab/window?

2011/02/10
1
514
2/10/2011 11:54:23 PM

Accepted Answer

Use "_blank"

According to the HTML5 Spec:

A valid browsing context name is any string with at least one character that does not start with a U+005F LOW LINE character. (Names starting with an underscore are reserved for special keywords.)

A valid browsing context name or keyword is any string that is either a valid browsing context name or that is an ASCII case-insensitive match for one of: _blank, _self, _parent, or _top." - Source

That means that there is no such keyword as _new in HTML5, and not in HTML4 (and consequently XHTML) either. That means, that there will be no consistent behavior whatsoever if you use this as a value for the target attribute.

Security recommendation

As Daniel and Michael have pointed out in the comments, when using target _blank pointing to an untrusted website, you should, in addition, set rel="noopener". This prevents the opening site to mess with the opener via JavaScript. See this post for more information.

2020/06/20
652
6/20/2020 9:12:55 AM

Using target="_blank" will instruct the browser to create a new browser tab or window when the user clicks on the link.

Using target="_new" is technically invalid according to the specifications, but as far as I know every browser will behave the same way:

  • it will search for a tab or window with the context name "_new"
  • if a "_new" tab/window is found, then the URL is loaded into it
  • if it's not found, a new tab/window is created with the context name "_new", and the URL loaded into it

Note target="_new" will behave exactly the same as target="new", and the latter is valid HTML while the former is invalid HTML.

Adding some confusion to this, in HTML4 the target attribute was deprecated. In HTML5 this decision was reversed, and it is an official part of the spec once again. All browsers support target no matter what version of HTML you are using, but some validators will flag the use as deprecated if your doctype is HTML4.

2012/01/15

TL;DR
USE _blank

The target attribute specifies where to open the linked document.

USAGE: target="xyz"  [don't forget double quotes]

_blank  Opens the linked document in a new window or tab
_self   Opens the linked document in the same frame as it was clicked (this is default)
_parent     Opens the linked document in the parent frame
_top    Opens the linked document in the full body of the window 
framename   Opens the linked document in a named frame

SINCE "_new" is not any of these IT WILL COME UNDER "framename" so if a user re-clicks on that hyperlink it will not open a new tab instead update the existing tab. Whereas in _blank if user clicks twice then 2 new tabs open.

2015/07/26

I know this is an old question and the correct answer, use _blank, has been mentioned several times, but using <a target="somesite.com" target="_blank">Link</a> is a security risk.

It is recommended (performance benefits) to use:

<a href="somesite.com" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Link</a>
2019/03/25

This may have been asked before but:

"every link that specifies target="_new" looks for and finds that window by name, and opens in it.

If you use target="_blank," a brand new window will be created each time, on top of the current window."

from here: http://thedesignspace.net/MT2archives/000316.html

2011/02/10

it's my understanding that target = whatever will look for a frame/window with that name. If not found, it will open up a new window with that name. If whatever == "_new", it will appear just as if you used _blank except.....

Using one of the reserved target names will bypass the "looking" phase. So, target = "_blank" on a dozen links will open up a dozen blank windows, but target = whatever on a dozen links will only open up one window. target = "_new" on a dozen links may give inconstant behavior. I haven't tried it on several browsers, but should only open up one window.

At least this is how I interpret the rules.

2013/02/14

Source: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4964130
Licensed under: CC-BY-SA with attribution
Not affiliated with: Stack Overflow
Email: [email protected]